Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Carmella's Pizzeria (Middletown NY)

Where do you think we would eat if our choices were Chinese buffet or pizzeria? If you guessed pizzeria, you are right, although we are not always this predictable. There were so many types of pizza at Carmella's it was overwhelming! Then add all the other food they had to offer, such as pasta and sandwiches, and it is almost too many options.

The Deac ordered a veal parm, while Cathy and I split three types of slices. We each ordered a white pizza slice, and split a slice of both cheese pizza, and deep dish pizza. We could already see the pizza was bigger then average at the counter, and then when we got the slices they were down right huge.The white pizza was a typical white pizza, and was Cathy's favorite out of all the pizza. The cheese pizza was my favorite, since I thought they pretty much perfected the sauce and the crust was thin. Then the deep dish pizza was so deep it was quoting poetry. The Deac's sandwich was also huge, and was covered with melted cheese.

Dining next to us were two lovely elderly ladies... Only thing is, one of them had a severe case of bronchitis and did not keep it a secret. Plus if burping is a compliment to the chef, she made the chef hear it... A LOT. But who can complain about the customers? Overall this place has a lot of interesting varieties of tasty pizza. Plus maybe we are just nosy, but we liked all the pictures of the family with their son who is in the military.


Food- 3.5
The food was good and for some reason if we were back in the playtog shopping center we would stop. Although we would not go out of our way to eat there, if you are in the area and do not know were to eat then stop at Carmella's Pizzeria.

Service-  4
The service was down right amazing since the girl serving us, was also cooking for us and was the only person working.

You can find Carmella's Pizzeria at 156 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940

No comments:

Post a Comment